Discover the Secrets of an Enchanted World

Wrong Directions: Secrets of the Compass Rose

Hidden History Compass Rose, by Tarl Telford

Compass Rose for the Hidden History of Oz. Note that the directions East and West are reversed from the "civilized world"

The compass rose in Oz has been a controversy for more than a century. The directions East and West are reversed on the first “official” map of Oz.

Was this a mistake? Or are directions truly different in Oz? 

Official Explanation

Let’s first examine the official explanation for the reversed compass rose and look at the map. Then we’ll look to the books for more information.

Map of Oz included in the endpapers of The Marvelous Land of Oz (book #2 in the canonical Oz series by Baum)

One of the original maps of Oz. Note that the compass rose is "normal", but the map is reversed - the Winkies are supposed to be in the West (here they are in the East).

The First Map

L. Frank Baum made a map on a glass slide that he used with his Fairylogue and Radio-Play traveling show. This map had a traditional compass rose, with the West on the left, and the East on the right. The first book that had a map had those directions reversed, and the compass adjusted to match the map. Oz scholars believe that Baum copied the map from the wrong side of the glass slide. That would make a mirror image of everything. When he realized this mistake, he corrected the compass rose to make it point the “normal” directions. Then an editor at Reilly and Lee (publisher of many Oz books) reversed the compass rose, thinking that he was fixing a mistake. This led to greater confusion.
Ruth Plumly Thompson, in her expanded universe Oz books, frequently used the reversed directions as a result of this “official” map.

Official Maps of Oz (video link)

Here is an excellent video overview of all of the official maps that have been associated with canonical Oz.

Wonderful Maps of Oz

Examples of East and West

Both the Hidden History stories and The Wonderful Wizard of Oz contain references to the directions in Oz.

Dorothy follows the sun

In The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, Dorothy knew which way she was going.  After she melted the Wicked Witch of the West, and they headed back to the Emerald City. Dorothy knew east from west.

It was much harder to find their way back through the big fields of buttercups and yellow daisies1 than it was being carried. They knew, of course, they must go straight east, toward the rising sun; and they started off in the right way. But at noon, when the sun was over their heads, they did not know which was east and which was west, and that was the reason they were lost in the great fields.
(The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, Chapter 14, The Winged Monkeys)

Glinda corrects Oscar’s compass rose

In the first book of the Hidden History series, The Witch Queens of Oz, Glinda and Oscar have this exchange on the compass rose:

Oscar gathered broken pieces of wood and glass to use for the cardinal points. “If this is a map, then North is up. East is right. South is down. West is left.” He placed everything in position and then stood back very proud of himself. He glanced over to Glinda for approval, and his self-admiration collapsed.
Glinda was laughing at him.
No, silly goose.” She shook her head. “East is left. West is right. Haven’t you watched the sun rise and set? What land are you from, anyway?” She giggled.
Oscar’s puzzled and confused look sent Glinda into another fit of giggles. “No. It’s cute. I’m sure you didn’t mean it.”
“Where I’m from, my directions were right.”
Glinda put her hands on her hips. “Well, you’re not where you’re from now, are you Mr. High-and-Mighty?”
(The Witch Queens of Oz, Chapter  27, The Fallen Tower)

Wrong Directions?

So what are we to deduce from all of this back and forth running? Is right East and left West in Oz? Let me ask you this – does it matter to you? If so, then you can choose which direction you want the sun to rise.

In the Hidden History of Oz series, I write the directions as they show on the map – left is East and right is West. This doesn’t change the direction that the sun actually rises in, only the side that the people believe the sun rises. This is very clear in the text.

From atop the Grand Tower in Central City, Mombi looked out toward the setting sun. That was where the armies would meet—at the place where the sun set. Ondri-baba’s army had been gone more than a day. If she marched through the night, the armies would meet the following evening.
(The Witch Queens of Oz, Chapter 30, The Escape to the East)

Ultimately, the directions you choose are based on the map you believe in. Follow the story and determine the best map for your travels. For myself, I am left asking the question, why would the people of Oz believe the reversed directions? Who or what in their history changed the compass rose?
That compass rose smells like a sweet story to me. That is the kind of question that motivates me in my exploration of the Hidden History of Oz.


3 responses

  1. There’s no scientific reason for east to be right and west left on a map; that’s just the way we do things in our culture. Perhaps it’s different in Oz.


    April 30, 2012 at 5:49 PM

  2. Pingback: Hidden History Map of Oz, circa 1852 « The Hidden History of Oz

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s